The High Cost of Milk Politics in Karnataka
| AUTHOR | Anupam Manur |
| DATE | November 19, 2026 |
| CATEGORIES | Economic Policy |
This is the unedited version of the article published in Deccan Herald. Link to the original article here
Do you want to stump your neighbourhood economist? Ask them to explain this. Karnataka has had a good monsoon and record milk production. Yet, dairy prices have jumped, and the state’s milk federation is worried about deep losses. How does more supply lead to higher prices and losses?
In the first week of November, Karnataka’s households and hotels took three dairy shocks. Nandini milk went up by ₹8 a litre. Curd went up by ₹14, to ₹68, until the Chief Minister stepped in and the Karnataka Milk Federation (KMF) agreed to take off ₹2. Then, on November 4, Nandini ghee rose from ₹715 to ₹850 a litre and a 500-gram pack of butter from ₹285 to ₹390.
Normally, one would assume steep price increases reflect a demand-supply mismatch. However, the opposite is true here. KMF is collecting more milk than at any time in its history. On a single day in April, it procured 1.2 crore litres of milk, against about 85 lakh litres a day a year earlier.
Prices have risen despite the glut because they are set in cabinet meetings, not by market forces. Both procurement and retail prices are administered. On October 29th, the Cabinet raised the price paid to farmers from ₹35 to ₹42 a litre, on top of an incentive of ₹5/litre. Further, KMF, being a cooperative, accepts every litre its members bring. A fixed price, an incentive, plus guaranteed procurement will surely result in excessive supply.
KMF sells about 62 to 65 lakh litres a day as milk, UHT milk and curd. That leaves quite a bit unsold. KMF, reportedly, converts about 25 lakh litres a day into milk powder, whose prices KMF does not control. Powder was fetching ₹205 to ₹210 a kg when unions needed over ₹235 to break even, and 15,000 tonnes lay unsold, tying up money owed to farmers. This is a recurrent story in Karnataka – a good monsoon becomes a financial problem.
Even with the price hike, the numbers don’t add up. Farmers have been promised ₹7 more on every litre they supply and consumers pay ₹8 more, but only on the milk it sells. Milk converted into powder brings in no profit; in fact, it is sold at a loss. On a rough estimate, that leaves KMF short by ₹2 to 3 crore a day.
This money must come from somewhere. The blue packet price is politically sensitive, so the shortfall is recovered from other products that attract less attention, like curd, ghee and butter. When the Chief Minister has to personally intervene to keep curd cheaper, that gap will be recovered from another product, from the state’s budgets or even to the farmer. In 2024, as powder piled up, the Kolar, Mandya and Raichur-Koppal-Ballari unions cut their procurement prices.
Supporting about 11 lakh farming families who rely on dairy maybe a legitimate goal. But, a per-litre price fixing is a poor instrument that results in excess production. And, when the government sets the price, it must be prepared for the anger that follows every increase.
Counter-intuitively, competition might help. There is no formal legislation that prevents other states’ dairies from selling fresh milk and curd in Karnataka, but state cooperatives have long had an informal understanding to stay off each other’s turf. When Amul proposed to sell milk and curd online in Bengaluru in 2023, there was a political storm and a boycott. The irony, of course, is that Nandini sells its products Mumbai, Hyderabad, Chennai and Delhi, as it should. Now, competition might bring in even more supply, but it would discipline both KMF’s prices and costs.
Four reforms would help farmers, consumers and Nandini as well. First, support dairy households through a direct transfer per family instead of a payment per litre, so that help reaches farmers without manufacturing a surplus. Second, take pricing out of the cabinet and place it in the hands of KMF’s board, who should set prices based on costs. The price changes can be proactively made in regular, small revisions instead of long freezes, followed by sudden jumps. Third, let the procurement prices vary by season, lower in flush and higher in lean seasons. A quantity cap on procurement could be considered as well to give clear signals to dairy farmers. Finally, welcome other states’ cooperatives and private dairies into Karnataka’s fresh dairy market, and ask KMF to publish its costs product by product.
Nandini is a great Karnataka institution that has been built by its farmers over five decades. It is strong enough to compete in other states and does not need protection from competition or basic economics. Both the procurement and market price should be allowed to reflect relative demand and supply.
Anupam Manur is a professor of economics at the Takshashila Institution